Boycotting Tropic Thunder?

Aug. 17, 2008
Google plus Linkedin Pinterest

After a month long reign at the top of the box office charts, The Dark Knight was finally eased off its throne by a new contender. Tropic Thunder took in $26 million this weekend, a paltry sum compared to DarkKnightís near $472 million purse since its release on July 18. Itís unlikely that the R-rated Ben Stiller comedy will stay on top for long. The Dark Knight struck a chord with many moviegoers while Tropic Thunder is a diversion, an excuse to get out of the house for a couple of hours.

Itís also an opportunity to assess the negligible impact of highly publicized boycotts by lobbying groups and special interests. I have not seen Tropic Thunder, am not especially interested in seeing it, canít weigh in on it and can only hope it wasnít mean spirited to any disadvantaged group. I can, however, say a few things.

First of all, making fun of people who poke fun at a minority isnít the same thing as poking fun at a minority. Itís sad that some advocates of the intellectually disabled are so intellectually dim that they canít make that distinction. (I especially direct my comments to the dull professor of ďdisabilities studiesĒ heard last week on NPR). If Tropic Thunder is actually being cruel to the mentally disabled (rather than its stated intention of satirizing Hollywood), I will join in condemning it. But like me, most of the people squawking about the movie havenít seen it. I suggest they reserve judgment until they do.

Secondly, ballyhooed boycotts almost always fail. For years the Roman Catholic Church boosted the revenues of films it disliked by calling on the faithful to boycott them. If everyone ignored Mel Gibson, ThePassion of the Christ might not have been as big a hit.

Finally, a democratic society is based on the premise that ideas should be exchanged and debated. You canít debate the merits of a movie you have chosen ahead of time not to see. Boycotting a film isnít the same thing as boycotting wine from South Africa during Apartheid or lettuce from non-union farms. Movies are commodities but they are also the conveyers of ideas and messagesógood, bad and mixed. If the message is abhorrent, treating the public like three-year olds and telling them to avert their eyes may not be the best way to combat them.

Log in to use your Facebook account with
Shepherd Express

Login With Facebook Account


Scott Walker has proposed virtually eliminating the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. If passed, do you believe that Walker’s proposal would directly or indirectly impact the health of you or your children?

Getting poll results. Please wait...