Road Map to Oblivion
He’s all over the cable news shows talking about his deficit reduction plan, “Roadmap for America’s Future.” Conservative George Will recently wrote a column forecasting him as the 2013 Republican vice president of the United States. Even President Barack Obama singled out Ryan as a pleasant guy with a nice family.
Actually, that last item should be the tip-off that all is not what it seems.
When was the last time Democrats were so eager to push a young Republican Congressman forward as a national figure? It’s almost as if they can’t wait to start a national debate on Republican budget proposals.
That’s because Ryan’s so-called “Roadmap for America’s Future” is so chock full of politically toxic ideas Democrats want everyone in the country to know exactly what would happen if Republicans ever got back into power—including privatizing Social Security so those retirement funds could be lost just like our 401(k)s were, dismantling Medicare and replacing it with a limited voucher program as unreformed health insurance costs continue to rise, and eliminating the top income tax brackets so that millionaires and billionaires would pay exactly the same rate as someone making $50,000 a year.
How about this one? Repealing all corporate taxes and replacing them with a consumption tax consumers would have to pay on every single thing they buy.
So far, Ryan appears clueless as to the real reason his ideas are getting so much attention. He’s flattered by the spotlight and dancing in it for everything he’s worth.
Of course, it’s easy to be misled by a fawning local media that seems star-struck by a “Kennedyesque” Wisconsin Congressman on national television. Few Wisconsin reporters have bothered to explore just how radical Ryan’s right-wing proposals are.
Then again, in an age of superficial media, maybe no one will get around to reporting just how bad some of Ryan’s ideas are for ordinary Americans. Maybe it’s enough to be young and good-looking on television.
Certainly, Ryan is a prettier face for the Republican Party than all those sour old men who form the current leadership. Every time the TV cameras sweep over their glowering faces during a “State of the Union” address, it’s like all of the air has been sucked out of that side of the room.
Some think Republicans are glad to have Ryan to point to right now to refute the criticism their party doesn’t have any ideas. All anyone knows about Republicans is that they are against whatever the president wants to do.
Reform health care? No! Create jobs? No! Stop the collapse of the nation’s financial system? No! Prevent American car manufacturers and all related employers from going out of business? No! Pull us back from the brink of another Great Depression? No!
In an economic crisis, maybe Republicans figure it’s better to have bad ideas than no ideas at all.
Even though not very many Republicans are coming forward to publicly embrace Ryan’s radical proposals going into the 2010 elections, they have trouble explaining exactly where they disagree with him. That’s because they don’t.
Same Old Beliefs
Ryan is a true believer. He really believes in destroying Social Security and Medicare and slashing taxes for the wealthy. Those aren’t new ideas. They are very old Republican ideas.
Republicans have opposed Social Security and Medicare as socialism since their creation by Democratic Presidents Franklin Delano Roosevelt in the ’30s and Lyndon Johnson in the ’60s.
That makes Ryan far more honest than those hypocritical Republicans who pretended to be concerned Democratic health care reform would cut Medicare for seniors—which it wouldn’t. Republicans routinely vote to cut Medicare.
But being honest about dismantling Medicare doesn’t make the effect any less devastating. Everyone agrees Medicare has been an extremely well-run program, at least until Republicans added a confusing prescription drug plan that was really a boondoggle for private insurance companies.
Ryan would replace it with a voucher for a fixed amount that seniors could use to buy private insurance—another boondoggle for the insurance industry.
Without health care reform, a voucher would buy less coverage for seniors all the time. The major health insurance companies—having avoided reform so far with the Republican election in Massachusetts—just announced whopping premium increases up to 39% despite increasing their profits by billions last year.
The reason Democrats are so eager to talk about Ryan’s “Roadmap” is they know where it leads.
President George W. Bush’s attempt to privatize Social Security at the start of his second term created such widespread public opposition that it led to the Democratic majorities in both houses of Congress.
Putting a pretty, new face on Bush’s disastrous economic policies doesn’t make it a road map to anywhere America wants to go.



Joel, I can smell your fear and flop-sweat from here. Only when liberals are deatly afraid of a conservative do they come at him this hard. But seriously Joel, is it too much to ask that you actually READ the Roadmap for America? You are so clueless and uninformed that you have to resort to scare tactics like "destroy Medicare" and "slash taxes". It is amazing that even a rag like the Shepherd lets you get away with this. Please, try to argue on the basis of the numbers, not your little scary words. Can you do that? I thought not.
You say McNally lies. You even accused him of being a liberal. Has the man no American values! Please give me facts showing where he is incorrect. No name calling please.
Joel McNally's Paul Ryan piece is on point. It's puzzling to me that his re-election campaigns haven't been more competitive. He certainly is far to the right of his district.
"Attention ineffectual and lazy liberals: if you are so clueless and ignorant to buy the crap that McNally is shoveling on weekly basis you are simply to stupid to be helped. You clowns sure are entertaining though."
It's hard to take seriously someone who never learned their to's and too's.
The guy that wrote that article must work for MSNBC. 1st, I would be more then happy to opt out of any Social Security earnings that I have built up today in order to invest that extra 6% of my income on my own. I promise you I would have a higher ROI then the government. And it wasn... See More’t a mandate by Bush, just an option (I believe it was limited at 2% of your income). 2nd They point out the market crash of 2008, what about the boom of the 90’s and now market is up 40% over the last year. I am almost back to where I was in 2007 as far as 401K is concerned. 3rd does the author really think Corporations pay taxes? They collect taxes from consumers, and pass them on to the government. Increase corporate taxes by 2%, it gets passed on to the consumer. If there was a consumer tax, everyone, would pay. Hookers, strippers, illegals, people getting paid under the table, everyone.
And it wasn't bush's stance on ss that lead to Democratic Majorities, it was the war stupid and economy stupid.