Beware of Responsible Citizens
That sweeping statement by an elected public official, Republican state Sen. Pam Galloway of Wausau, is so monumentally ignorant it should drop the jaw of every single citizen in the state of Wisconsin.
After all, “private citizens carrying concealed weapons” defines every murderous thug who has ever committed an armed robbery or shot and killed another human being on our streets.
That such an ignorant statement could come from an actual elected official who has been given authority to create laws by a vote of other citizens in her community should give everyone pause, regardless of political party.
The concept of ignorance now must be redefined. Galloway is not some uneducated woman living among violent rabble in a backwoods hollow somewhere who fails to grasp the rules of decent society. She is a college-educated medical doctor and surgeon who, in the Republican rout of 2010, defeated Democratic Senate Majority Leader Russ Decker, who had represented the district for a decade.
Galloway comes from the right as a past chairwoman of the Marathon County Republican Party and a member of Wisconsin Right to Life and the National Rifle Association.
But political views, whether from the right or the left, don't have to be blatantly ignorant.
We all need to ask ourselves why the important debate over the availability of deadly weapons in this country is now dominated by extremist rhetoric that is demonstrably absurd.
With Republicans controlling the governor's office and both houses of the Legislature for now, few people doubt the NRA's pet cause, concealed carry of deadly weapons, will pass in Wisconsin.
Only vetoes by Democratic Gov. Jim Doyle spared the state from concealed carry laws Republicans passed when they controlled the Legislature in 2003 and 2005.
That makes it even more important that any law increasing the number of guns on our streets include some common-sense protections for public safety.
Instead, one proposed concealed carry bill Galloway co-authored with Republican state Rep. Jeff Mursau of Crivitz allows anyone who hasn't committed a violent crime to carry a concealed gun without a permit or even any background check.
No age requirements. No law enforcement oversight. No way of knowing whether the people with deadly weapons on our streets might be crazy as outhouse rats.
Why bother with any paperwork? Just let the bullets fly.
Surprising Lack of Concern
Without any concerned adults overseeing state legislation while Republicans are in control, Wisconsin would be transformed from one of the few states in the country where concealed carry is banned into one of the few states in the country with no sensible controls at all on anyone carrying lethal weapons.
Such a complete lack of concern for public safety is surprising in a state where the popular sport of hunting emphasizes respect for the deadly power of the gun.
Basic hunter education classes include at least 10 hours of lessons emphasizing gun safety and accident prevention. Police officers and other law enforcement professionals train and practice throughout their careers to maintain their skills in using their guns without unnecessarily endangering public safety.
But all the amateurs who would be packing heat in public places under concealed carry can't be inconvenienced by onerous requirements they actually learn common-sense precautions to prevent them from accidentally slaughtering innocent human beings.
Oh, wait. Some people would be protected from all those responsible citizens carrying deadly weapons. Those fortunate few are the people who pass and enforce our laws.
Even under concealed carry, guns still would be banned from the Capitol where Galloway works as well as from police stations, jails and prisons, courthouses, airports, schools and other government buildings.
While Galloway and her fellow legislators are protected, the rest of us had better keep our heads down. We never know when we might get taken out by some untrained responsible citizen.
All of us can think of places where lethal weapons never should be permitted—day care centers, churches, shelters where battered women flee violent and abusive relationships. Galloway couldn't care less.
How did the debate over guns reach the point where pro-gun politicians such as Galloway consider people who are concerned about gun safety their enemies and every gunslinger a responsible citizen?
Some kind of cartoon version of the world has replaced intelligent discussion of guns in this state.
Anyone who would like some common-sense controls and safety education in place for amateurs who are going to be armed and dangerous in public is anti-gun.
Anyone who wants to carry a deadly weapon is a responsible citizen.
Neither of those descriptions covers the vast majority of hunters who embrace gun safety to protect themselves and their friends in the woods or the vast majority of citizens who have always carried and used guns on our streets.



The easiest way to deal with criminals who use a weapon in the act of a crime is to simply amputate hands and release them. Guns don't kill people, its all in the hands of criminals. You can do the same with drunk drivers and child molesters. Quick easy cure. No need for jails.
Gee, David, how Medieval or Biblical of you!
And you will amputate upon arrest, before trial and conviction by jury of your peers... Correction, jury of Voters who carry ID?
The reason they used to cut off a thief's right hand was that the people in Moses time used their right hand to reach into the community food pot, but used their left hand where toilet paper, Sears catalogs, and corn cobs were not yet available. So when your right hand was cut off, left hand being all that you had left, you could no longer eat, you had to leave town. It was exhile and a practical death sentence, without needing some good citizen to deal the killing blow.
Later it was an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. Since real people tend to want vengeance 10-fold, Jesus said to treat that eye for an eye as an upper limit, not a starting point!
Hey WaukeshaGuy, will the tune change when ANOTHER mass shooting by some crazy down there takes place? Been a coupla years since the last one I believe. Ever notice there's never a shooting nor robbery @ a gun show or a gun store?
There are what, 48 states that allow concealed carry? Notice that McNally doesn't provide any examples of the horrors that concealed carry laws bring to these 48 states. There ARE NO HORROR STORIES! There are no stats that even suggest that concealed carry increases crime, gunplay, or even smack talk.
McNally is not really even a gun-hater. In a rather shrewd (but now tired and overplayed) way, McNally transfers the guilt of a group of democratic voters onto an inanimate object- the gun. Democratic constituents from the inner city don't kill people- guns kill people, right Joel?
Amen, brother. As a fellow Christian-conservative, I completely agree. Pam Galloway is a wonderful lady, and sets a good example for our well-being.
I've had a couple of events in my life that would have warranted the use of a weapon in self-defense. I hope this passes becasue my neighborhood is changing, and I'll need to conceal.
God bless!
I agree - There are 48 other states that have been there done that. Some decades ago. Why are we discussing this like we are on the cutting edge. Now the trend of the 48 is to convert to constitutional carry. Many have already.
Law breakers already carry concealed. It is high time Wi. allow the law abiding to do the same. The streets will be safer. Look up the stats in John Lot's book -
More Guns Less Crime
Upon a second (painful) reading of this article- the title jumps out. Although McNally waxes painful about the ignorant statement of a Wausau-area Republican politician, the truly igonorant statement is the title of this story. Could there be anything more short-sighted, more socialist, and less logical than "Beware of Responsible Citizens"???
Joel does not believe that there exists such thing as a responsible citizen- only citizens ruled by an all-encompassing government.
I think once McNally gets robbed enough he will become a Republican. He still lives in a fantacyland where he thinks all millionaires are rich people. I've spoken with a few politicians latley of both parties and most of them are carrying heat right now. There are a lot of insanists out there who are convinced the goverment is out to get them. We just need to do some Chinese/Arab forms of punishment for criminals. Anyone who ever uses a gun in the act of a premeditated crime should never ever see the light of day again. The only exceptions is if you are a parent and someone molested your kid or your are a store owner and you shoot theives as they are leaving your store. Or you find someone in your house or driving your stolen car. Those are justifiable homicides.
*FANTASY