Why We Can't Just ‘Look Forward’
Torture violated ethics and laws
Looking forward is one of those clichés that always
sounds positive and sensible, and certainly serves the president's political
interests. But the years of detainee abuse and constitutional violations cannot
be dismissed so easily, because the past is still with us—and so are the
dangers that drew America's
leaders toward the dark side.
That is why Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez, the retired
commander of U.S. and allied
forces in Iraq, repeated his
call for a "truth commission" in a New York University
auditorium on the evening of June 7. He joined a group of prominent writers,
lawyers and actors in staging an extraordinary event titled "Blueprint for
Accountability," which sought to revive pressure on the Obama
administration to fulfill its early promises to restore the Constitution, the
Geneva Convention and the rule of law. The house was packed, and there was a
sense that the president's supporters are deeply disappointed—and determined to
demand that he live up to his word.
Disturbing Report About Doctors and
Detainees
What sharply underscored their concern was a
disturbing report issued the same day by Physicians for Human Rights (PHR),
charging that doctors who observed "enhanced interrogation" sessions
for the CIA may have participated in illegal medical experimentation on
detainees.
By gathering data to assess the effects of
"waterboarding," painful stress positions, sleep deprivation,
humiliating nudity, extreme temperatures and other abusive techniques, those
doctors and other medical personnel risked violating both U.S. and
international laws that prohibit such research on any human beings without
their informed consent.
The CIA immediately and predictably denied the
report, insisting that the officers who oversaw its "past detention
program" conducted no such experimentation "on any detainee or group
of detainees." An agency spokesman assured reporters that its practices
have passed careful scrutiny in multiple reviews by the government, including
one by the Justice Department.
But the PHR report is based on information found by
the group's researchers in thousands of pages of partially redacted documents
released by the government in response to Freedom of Information Act lawsuits.
Those documents suggest that doctors helped to enable "the routine
practice of torture" by closely monitoring the physical state of prisoners
undergoing interrogation—supposedly to protect them from the severe damage that
would, in the opinion of Bush administration lawyers, skirt the edge of
legality. Most legal experts believe that the practices condoned by those
lawyers were indeed grossly illegal under both U.S. and international law.
The same documents also indicate that CIA medical
personnel recorded every aspect of each simulated drowning session and
collected detailed medical information that was then used to "design,
develop and deploy subsequent waterboarding procedures," according to the
PHR report. The doctors prescribed the addition of salt to the water because
they believed that higher salinity solutions would reduce the risk of illness,
coma or death. They also sought to determine whether simultaneous or sequential
application of various torments worked best, and analyzed other evidence of the
"susceptibility" of prisoners to pain and suffering such as that
caused by sleep deprivation.
"Such acts may be seen as the conduct of
research and experimentation by health professionals on prisoners, which could
violate accepted standards of medical ethics, as well as domestic and
international law," the report says. "These practices could, in some
cases, constitute war crimes and crimes against humanity."
Should the PHR report's accusations prove true, then
the United States took yet
another step toward the criminality that our government once prosecuted at Nuremberg. That is a
truth we must face forthrightly, as a nation, if we want to hold our heads up
and look forward again.
© 2010Creators.com



Your liberal clowns are comparing the atrocities committed by Nazi Germany and the Third Reich to a little waterboarding?! You bozos are downright delusional yet somehow still entertaining.